Utah HP tasers John Gardner

[UtahDan]

Originally Posted by il Padrino Ute

You practice criminal law? Then perhaps you can answer me this:

Why isn't "because he deserved it" a valid defense to homicide? It should be. Perhaps "the world is a better place with him dead" would be a better approach?

The easy answer is because the collective gets to decide whether he deserves "it" through due process, not an individual. It is a crappy system but better than any other yet devised.

[Cali Coug]

Originally Posted by UtahDan

The easy answer is because the collective gets to decide whether he deserves "it" through due process, not an individual. It is a crappy system but better than any other yet devised.

That is a great answer. I doubt anyone would want any person with enough money to purchase a gun to decide whether or not they "deserved" it.