[Levin]

I read the article, and Mike's argument is still ignorant. But like the baby he is, he takes his toys and goes to play with the posse who can stand to listen to his "subtle" and "quiet" playing.

What life experience did DFW not have that was required? Is there some essential life experience novelists must have to write the redemptive novel? What is it?

I would argue that there's no required "life experience" -- living is experience enough -- and all that's required is honesty, sensitivity, and self-reflection. And, of course, the writer's gift. And DFW had them all. But he just didn't have it in him to write the novel he wanted. Not all good writers do. But at least he tried before he gave up. Better than not trying at all so there's nothing to give up.