His career stats:
Career GP GS MIN AVG FG-FGA FG% 3P-3PA 3P% FT-FTA FT% OFF DEF REB AVG AST AVG BLK STL PF TO PTS AVG
2010-2011 0 0 0 N/A 0-0 N/A 0-0 N/A 0-0 N/A 0 0 0 N/A 0 N/A 0 0 0 0 0 N/A
2011-2012 34 15 551 16.2 48-131 .366 25-84 .298 26-41 .634 3 50 53 1.6 57 1.7 3 35 40 32 147 4.3
2012-2013 31 1 250 8.1 19-50 .380 5-20 .250 21-33 .636 8 24 32 1.0 16 0.5 2 13 28 9 64 2.1
2013-2014 20 2 292 14.6 43-85 .506 15-41 .366 17-26 .654 3 28 31 1.6 27 1.4 1 9 30 8 118 5.9
CAREER 85 18 1093 12.9 110-266 .414 45-145 .310 64-100 .640 14 102 116 1.4 100 1.2 6 57 98 49 329 3.9
http://byucougars.com/athlete/m-basketball/anson-winder
He's shooting better this year. But he had some games at the beginning of the year where the other team was leaving him open and he couldn't hit a thing. Then Bartley came in and performed better. And frankly Halford has performed better as well.
I would say the gap in defense between Winder and those two is negligible. Winder is no more a shut down defender than those two.
His redshirt freshman year, when he played big minutes, he shot .366 from the field. That is BAD. That includes layups. That means he was was probably shooting under .300 for jump shots.
I know you like the kid cause he's from Las Vegas. But I would argue he does not deserve to have all these minutes over Bartley. Bartley's upside is MUCH greater. And his current performance exceed's Winder's. What kind of minutes is Winder going to get next year? Probably less.