I admit I wanted Kyle. So did most of CB. A poll at the time had KW favored over Bronco at least 3:1. Right now it's hard to find guys admitting they wanted KW, so most everybody's lying about it, IMHO.
I'm glad we have Bronco, but I wouldn't say that after 2.75 seasons, you could say who's done the better coaching job, or whether or not KW would've done better at BYU.
KW's done an incredible job with in-state/LDS recruiting, challenging BYU for the top guys consistently for the first time ever.
Head to head: edge to KW. 2005 coaching job: edge to KW. 2006 coaching job: edge to Bronco. 2007 coaching job: wash so far, let's see how it turns out.
Some ways I'm NOT going to evaluate the two coaches on is:
who is a better fireside speaker
who is more "classy"
who is morally superior