Why do we bother any more?
With domestic partnerships and "marriage", it seems we spend a lot of time fighting over a distinction with barely a difference.
We fight over symbols. In the past fights were over something, such as freedom, voting, and matters that really affected lives. Now we fight over little picture items using the language of the big picture items, almost mocking the accomplishments of the past by invoking them in a pipsqueak debate. Has our philosophical life become so meaningless? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
This isn't about education, physical facilities, places on the bus, voting, or anything else affecting daily life. This is about a title in front of name, or "legitimacy", and maybe some extra insurance. It's a terrible analogy and comparison and mocks the lives of those who fought for something noble. |
Quote:
What if homosexuals took control of the government of Nevada and managed to change the state constitution to provide that men and women cannot marry each other; that people can only marry their own gender? If you lived in that state, wouldn't you consider it an abridgment of your civil liberties? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
May gays vote? Yes. May gays own property? Yes. May you fail to hire on the basis of orientation? In most cases, no. May gays cohabitate? Yes. May gays own property together? Yes. May gays conjugate? Yes. May gays have the name of Mr. and Mrs. legally? No. May gays have instruments conveying property upon death? Yes. I don't see much functionality in this debate. And if I were denied the right to legal recognition, so what. The Church should get out of the business of "marriage" and focus upon "sealings". Sealing is a noble construct, marriage is a social construct that means whatever subcultures say it means. Do away with the legal recognition of "marriage" altogether, make them all domestic partnerships or civil unions, and let the Churches decide upon what else should be heaped upon the union. That solution is much more elegant in my opinion. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
It is akin to Mormons laying claim to an analogy to the Jewish persecution of the Holocaust when they point to Haun's Mill. A mere shadow, and a mockery of the memories of those truly persecuted. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:08 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.